Bagels
1. Bagel Masters
661 Broad St
Shrewsbury
732.224.0333
bagelmasters.com
2. Grandma Gem’s House of Bagels
479 Prospect Ave
Little Silver
732.219.8989
grandmas-bagels.edan.io
3. Hole Lot of Bagels
171 Rte. 35
Middletown Township
732.706.9300
Bakery
1. Chocolate Carousel
2510 Belmar Blvd.
Wall Township
732.280.0606
chocolatecarousel.com
2. J & M Bakery
1120 Rte. 35
Middletown Township
732.671.4400
jandmitalianbakery.com
3. David Burke’s Dixie Lee Bakery
303 Main St.
Keansburg
732.787.0674
dixieleebakerybydb.com
Barbecue
1. Local Smoke
Multiple locations
localsmokebbq.com
2. Mutiny BBQ Company
808 Fifth Ave.
Asbury Park
732.366.9985
mutinybbq.com
3. Big Ed’s Barbecue (TIE)
305 Rte. 34
Matawan
732.583.2626
bigedsbbq.com
3. Monty’s BBQ (TIE)
71 First Ave.
Atlantic Highlands
732.204.2437
montysnjbbq.com
Bar Food
1. The Proving Ground
56 Shrewsbury Ave.
Highlands
732.872.2266
theprovingground.com
2. The Squire at Branches (TIE)
23 Monmouth Rd.
West Long Branch
866.778.4738
thesquirenj.com
2. Tommy’s Tavern + Tap (TIE)
Multiple locations
tommystavernandtap.com
3. Hey Burger NJ (TIE)
180 NJ-36
Hazlet
732.769.2300
heyburgernj.net
3. Topgolf Swing Suite at iPlay America (TIE)
106 Schanck Rd.
Freehold
732.577.8200
swingsuite.topgolf.com
Breakfast
1. Turning Point
Multiple locations
theturningpoint.biz
2. Cardinal Provisions
513 Bangs Ave.
Asbury Park
732.898.7194
crdnal.com
3. Sissy’s At the Harbor
8 Simon Lake Dr.
Atlantic Highlands
732.291.2218
Burgers
1. Barnacle Bill’s
1 First St.
Rumson
732.747.8396
barnaclebillsrumson.com
2. Hey Burger NJ
180 Rte. 36
Hazlet
732.769.2300
heyburgernj.net
3. The Proving Ground
56 Shrewsbury Ave.
Highlands
732.872.2266
theprovingground.com
Butcher
1. Monmouth Meats
112 Monmouth St.
Red Bank
732.741.5292
monmouthmeats.com
2. Palmer’s Quality Meats
40 Steiner Ave.
Neptune City
732.361.5599
3. Pop’s Butcher Shop
175 Monmouth Rd. #7
West Long Branch
732.571.7677
popsbutchershop.com
BYO Restaurant
1. Anjelica’s Restaurant
1070 Ocean Ave. N.
Sea Bright
732.842.2800
anjelicas.com
2. Semolina Restaurant (TIE)
13 White St.
Red Bank
732.945.6816
semolinarestaurant.com
2. Drew’s Bayshore Bistro (TIE)
44 E. Front St.
Keyport
732.739.9219
drewsbayshorebistro.com
3. Patricia’s of Holmdel
2132 NJ-35
Holmdel
732.275.0234
patriciasofholmdel.com
Candy/Chocolates
1. Chocolate Carousel
2510 Belmar Blvd.
Wall Township
732.280.0606
chocolatecarousel.com
2. Suzi’s Sweet Shoppe
1100 Rte. 35
Middletown
732.796.0115
suzisweetshoppe.com
3. Jeweled Studio Boutique
305 Rte. 9 South
Manalapan
732.303.9433
jeweledstudio.com
Caterer
1. Chef Collins Events
413 Sixth Ave.
Asbury Park
732.239.1218
chefcollins.com
2. Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet
500 NJ-35 Suite 7G
Red Bank
732.576.1888
talierciosdeli.com
3. Falco’s Catering
1110 NJ-35
Ocean Township
732.660.9000
falcoscatering.com
Cheese shop
1. Fourchette Red Bank
132 Broad St.
Red Bank
732.268.7928
fourchette-fromage.com
2. Uncle Giuseppe’s Marketplace
990 Shrewsbury Ave.
Tinton Falls
732.380.7744
uncleg.com
3. Cheese on Main
53 Main Ave.
Ocean Grove, Neptune Township
732.775.1530
Coffee/Tea House
1. Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters
171 First Ave.
Atlantic Highlands
732.708.0800
fairmountaincoffee.com
2. Steady Hand Cafe & Collective
408 7th Ave.
Asbury Park
908.334.3415
steadyhandcollective.com
3. Rook Coffee
Multiple locations
rookcoffee.com
Craft Brewery
1. Carton Brewing
6 E. Washington Ave.
Atlantic Highlands
732.654.2337
cartonbrewing.com
2. Belford Brewing Company
84 Leonardville Rd.
Belford
732.769.7168
belfordbrewing.com
3. Kane Brewing Company
1750 Bloomsbury Ave.
Ocean Township
kanebrewing.com
Cupcakes
1. Chocolate Carousel
2510 Belmar Blvd.
Wall Township
732.280.0606
chocolatecarousel.com
2. Cupcake Magician
54 Monmouth St.
Red Bank
732.530.5700
cupcakemagicianonline.com
3. Cups and Cakes Bakery
122 E River Rd.
Rumson
732.842.8080
cupsandcakesrumson.com
Donuts
1. Dunkin’ Donuts
Multiple locations
dunkindonuts.com
2. Once Bitten Donuts
86 Broad St.
Red Bank
848.308.2411
3. Broad Street Dough Co.
177 Elton Adelphia Rd.
Freehold
732.303.9000
2005 Rte. 35
Oakhurst
732.531.1401
broadstreetdoughco.com
Farmers Market
1. Galleria Red Bank Farmer’s Market
Corner of Bridge Avenue & West Front Street
Red Bank
732.530.7300
thegalleriaredbank.com
2. Asbury Fresh Farmers and Makers Market
Library Park Asbury Ave. & Grand Ave.
Asbury Park
732.481.4691
asburyfresh.com
3. Delicious Orchards
320 Rte. 34
Colts Neck
732.462.1989
deliciousorchardsnj.com
French Restaurant
1. Pascal & Sabine
601 Bangs Ave.
Asbury Park
732.774.3395
pascalandsabine.com
2. The French Market
114 E. River Rd.
Rumson
732.530.1692
Thefrenchmarketnj.com
Gluten-Free Goodies
1. Taste and Technique
60 River Rd.
Fair Haven
732.741.2665
tasteandtechniquenj.com
2. Papa Ganache
106 Main St.
Matawan
217 Main St.
Manasquan
732.217.1750
papaganache.com
3. Chocolate Carousel
2510 Belmar Blvd.
Wall Township
732.280.0606
chocolatecarousel.com
Gourmet Grocery
1. Uncle Giuseppe’s Marketplace
990 Shrewsbury Ave.
Tinton Falls
732.380.7744
uncleg.com
2. Livoti’s Old World Market
Multiple locations
livotisoldworldmarket.com
3. Delicious Orchards
320 Rte. 34
Colts Neck
732.462.1989
deliciousorchardsnj.com
Greek Restaurant
1. The Greek Spot
1013 Rte. 35
Ocean Township
732.531.7770
15 North Bridge Ave.
Red Bank
732.704.3255
thegreekspotnj.com
2. It’s Greek to Me *
Multiple locations
itsgreektome.com
3. Mr. Greek (TIE)
821 Belmar Blvd. Unit 5
Belmar
848.404.9633
mrgreekbelmar.com
3. Greek Eats Authentic Rotisserie (TIE)
89 Newman Springs Rd.
Shrewsbury
732.530.0777
gogreekeats.com
Health and Food Store
1. Green’s Natural Market
490 Broad St.
Shrewsbury
732.842.8686
119 Rte. 35
Ocean Township
732.517.1515
greensnaturalfoods.com
2. Healthfair Natural Food Market
625 Branch Ave.
Little Silver
732.747.3140
Healthfairvitamins.com
3. Whole Foods Market
Red Bank
471 NJ-35
732.758.1688
wholefoodsmarket.com
Ice Cream
1. Nicholas Creamery
Multiple locations
nicholascreamery.com
2. Hoffman’s Ice Cream
569 Church St.
Spring Lake
732.974.2253
hoffmansicecream.net
3. Crazees
2 W. River Rd.
Rumson
732.530.6543
crazees.com
Indian Restaurant
1. Mauka Indian Cuisine
78 NJ-35
Eatontown
732.876.4765
maukaindiancuisine.com
2. Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine
1178 Rte. 35
Middletown
732.671.8900
neelamindiancuisine.com
3. Bombay River
90 Broad St.
Red Bank
732.530.1598
bombayriver.com
Italian Deli
1. Taliercio’s Gourmet Deli
500 Rte. 35 #7g
Red Bank
732.576.1888
talierciosdeli.com
2. Livoti’s Old World Market
Multiple locations
livotisoldworldmarket.com
3. Angelo’s Italian Market
68 Oceanport Ave.
Little Silver
732.383.7373
angeloitalianmarket.com
Italian Restaurant
1. Ristorante Maietta
11 Tennent Ave.
Englishtown
732.446.7387
maiettas.com
2. Anjelica’s Restaurant
1070 Ocean Ave. N.
Sea Bright
732.842.2800
anjelicas.com
3. Nettie’s
5119 Asbury Ave.
Tinton Fall
732.922.9799
Japanese Restaurant
1. Taka Asbury
660 Cookman Ave.
Asbury Park
732.775.1020
takaasbury.com
2. Sono Sushi
1098 Rte. 35
Middletown
732.706.3588
Sonosushi.net
3. Ichiban Holmdel Japanese Restaurant
2101 NJ-35
Holmdel
732.671.0888
ichibanholmdelnj.com
Mexican Restaurant
1. Juanito’s
159 Monmouth St.
Red Bank
732.747.9118
juanitosredbank.com
2. Rosalita’s Roadside Cantina
1048 Cedar Bridge Ave.
Brick
732.739.7055
180 Rte. 9 North
Englishtown
732.617.0099
rosiescantinanj.com
3. El Señor Pepper’s
60 Bridge Ave.
Red Bank
732.741.1211
elsenorpeppers.wixsite.com
New Restaurant
1. The Squire at Branches
123 Monmouth Rd.
West Long Branch
866.778.4738
thesquirenj.com
2. Lita
1055 NJ-34
Aberdeen Township
732.696.8517
thelovelylita.com
3. Ember & Eagle
2000 Lowther Dr.
Eatontown
732.443.3009
Outdoor Dining
1. The Proving Ground
56 Shrewsbury Ave.
Highlands
732.872.2266
theprovingground.com
2. Marina Grille
905 NJ-35
Belmar
732.894.3211
marinagrillenj.com
3. Beach Tavern
33 West St.
Monmouth Beach
beachtavernnj.com
Pies
1. Delicious Orchards
320 Rte. 34
Colts Neck
732.462.1989
deliciousorchardsnj.com
2. Chocolate Carousel
2510 Belmar Blvd.
Wall Township
732.280.0606
Chocolatecarousel.com
3. Long Branch Poultry Farm (TIE)
264 Branchport Ave.
Long Branch
732.222.2464
3. Cups and Cakes Bakery (TIE)
122 E River Rd.
Rumson
732.842.8080
cupsandcakesrumson.com
Pizza
1. The Brothers Restaurant
188 W Front St.
Red Bank
732.530.3356
2. Pete & Elda’s Bar/Carmen’s Pizzeria (TIE)
96 Woodland Ave.
Neptune City
732.774.6010
peteandeldas.com
2. Vic’s Italian American Restaurant (TIE)
60 Main St.
Bradley Beach
732.774.8225
vicspizza.com
3. The Galley Pizza & Eatery
1313 Memorial Dr.
Asbury Park
732.775.7711
thegalleyasbury.com
Romantic Restaurant
1. The Squire at Branches
23 Monmouth Rd.
West Long Branch
866.778.4738
thesquirenj.com
2. Pascal & Sabine
601 Bangs Ave.
Asbury Park
732.774.3395
pascalandsabine.com
3. Anjelica’s Restaurant (TIE)
1070 Ocean Ave. N.
Sea Bright
732.842.2800
anjelicas.com
3. 618 Restaurant (TIE)
618 Park Ave.
Freehold Township
732.577.0001
618nj.com
Seafood Restaurant
1. Bahrs Landing
2 Bay Ave.
Highlands
732.872.1245
bahrslanding.com
2. Navesink Fishery
1004 NJ-36
Atlantic Highlands
732.291.8017
navesinkfishery.com
3. 2nd Jetty
140 Ocean Ave. N.
Sea Bright
732.224.8700
2ndjetty.com
Steakhouse
1. The Butcher’s Block
235 West Ave.
Long Branch
thebutchersblocknj.com
2. Gabriella’s Italian Steakhouse
447 Rte. 35
732.456.6699
gabriellasnj.com
3. Char Steakhouse
33 Broad St.
Red Bank
732.450.2427
Charsteakhouse.com
Thai Restaurant
1. Kunya Siam Thai Restaurant
99 First Ave.
Atlantic Highlands
732.291.0251
kunyasiam.com
2. Bamboo Leaf
722-724 Main St.
Bradley Beach
732.774.1661
bambooleafthaieatery.com
3. Bangkok House
26 Rte. 35
Eatontown
732.389.3890
bangkokhousenj.com
Vegetarian Restaurant
1. Good Karma Café
17 East Front St.
Red Bank
732.450.8344
goodkarmacafenj.com
2. Kaya’s Kitchen
1000 Main St.
Belmar
732.280.1141
Kayaskitchenbelmar.com
3. Cats Luck (TIE)
140 Steiner Ave.
Neptune City
732.361.7294
catsluckvegan.com
3. Seed to Sprout (TIE)
Multiple locations
Seedtosproutnj.com
Waterfront Dining
1. The Proving Ground
56 Shrewsbury Ave.
Highlands
732.872.2266
theprovingground.com
2. Bahrs Landing
2 Bay Ave.
Highlands
732.872.1245
bahrslanding.com
3. Rooney’s Oceanfront Restaurant
100 Ocean Ave. N.
Long Branch
732.870.1200
rooneysocean.com
Wings
1. Tommy’s Tavern + Tap
Multiple locations
tommystavernandtap.com
2. The Proving Ground
56 Shrewsbury Ave.
Highlands
732.872.2266
theprovingground.com
3. The Squire at Branches
23 Monmouth Rd.
West Long Branch
866.778.4738
thesquirenj.com
FREE: SIGN UP HERE FOR OUR WEEKLY E-NEWSLETTER AND DIGITAL EDITION OF BERGEN MAGAZINE
