8 Caterers So You Can Chill Vs. Grill

Don’t want to stand over a hot grill this MDW? Let these experts create a delicious, no-fuss summer spread.

A classic Memorial Day get-together includes a fantastic cookout spread, but not everyone can be a grill master. Maybe you’re worried about overcooking the burgers or maybe you just don’t feel like manning the flames all afternoon—whatever your reason, you don’t need to sweat it. There are plenty of local pros ready to step in and save the day.

If you’re looking for crowd-pleasing barbecue spreads or deli platters that disappear in minutes, these caterers and shops (many are recent Readers’ Choice winners and each highly rated) make it easy to throw a laid-back, delicious party—no tongs required. All you have to do is show up, serve it up and enjoy the compliments.

• The American BBQ Company. You’ll find 30 years of catering experience here, and you can taste it in every bite. From a full American barbecue to “backyard basics” (burgers, hot dogs and cold salads) or “summer essentials” (add sausage and peppers, barbeque chicken and corn), here’s a spread to please a crowd.
  *94-1 Ford Rd., Denville, 973.664.1460

• Anthony & Son’s. Two convenient locations ensure that good food is never far with this option. Create the perfect menu for your gathering with cold sandwiches, antipasto platters and lots of protein options.
  *20 Luger Rd., Denville, 973.625.2323; 15 Rte. 10, East Succasunna, 973.970.9191
  
• Burrini’s Olde World Italian Market. There are Italian classics here, of course, but Burrini’s will also cater barbecue ribs, wings, pulled pork, pepper steak and more.
  *1204 Sussex Tpke., Randolph, 973.895.6100
  
• Calandra’s Italian Market & Deli. This spot took first place for Best Caterer in 2025, and a glance at the menu makes it clear why people are raving. Special holiday packages offer themed pasta, protein and appetizers, or browse the general menu for sandwich platters, salads, dozens of side options and pastries for dessert.
  *234 Bloomfield Ave., Caldwell, 973.226.8889
  
• Ferraro’s Italian Deli. The catering at this family-owned spot is always a hit—make sure you keep an eye out for holiday-specific menus! And if that doesn’t tickle your fancy, create your own with options like fried ravioli, stuffed mushrooms and roasted veggies.
  *166 Halsey Rd., Parsippany, 973.585.4292
  
• KB’s BBQ Smokehouse. Fantastic barbecue has never been easier thanks to the award-winning KB’s catering menu. Think smoked wings, pulled pork and ribs with corn, candied yams and the famous five-cheese mac on the side.
  *1077 Stuyvesant Ave., Irvington, 973.982.6528
  
• Sergio & Co. Please your cookout crowd with sausage and peppers, classic potato salad, roasted beet salad with pistachios and sandwiches galore.
  *28 Broadway, Denville, 973.627.1043
• Uncle Giuseppe’s. This upscale, small chain market can provide the fixings to make a great MDW spread yourself, of course, but be sure to browse the catering menu. It offers everything from full hot buffets filled with pasta to cold sandwiches and small bites to sushi (wouldn’t that be a surprise to your guests!).
  *1171 Rte. 10, Morris Plains, 862.242.8320

Have a MDW spread worth showing off? Make sure you tag us on Instagram @morrisandessexmag in all your best moments.